Blog Impeachment Could Be Both Bad News and Good News for Trade Policy We believe the impeachment inquiry could have an adverse impact on the ongoing U.S.–China trade conflict, but there may be a silver lining for NAFTA 2.0.
These are extraordinary times in Washington, D.C., in which President Donald Trump is only the fourth president in U.S. history to face an impeachment inquiry. Regardless of the outcome, the impeachment proceedings will likely dominate Washington for the foreseeable future. The common narrative in the financial markets is that impeachment will crowd out everything else and that nothing productive will get done in Washington, which will only reinforce the skittishness and uncertainty in markets. We think that assessment is more right than wrong, but we also note that there may be an underappreciated silver lining to the impeachment inquiry. Clouded outlook for U.S.–China trade negotiations First, the not so good: We believe impeachment could have an adverse impact on the ongoing U.S.–China trade conflict, the policy issue that has disproportionately weighed on financial markets over the past two years. PIMCO flagged trade policy as a likely source of uncertainty soon after President Trump’s inauguration, reminding investors not to underestimate the president’s long-standing belief that the U.S. has been shortchanged on trade with foreign countries – particularly China – for decades, not to mention his affinity for tariffs as a negotiating tool. Fast-forward almost three years: The U.S. has already imposed tariffs on more than $360 billion of imported Chinese goods, and the conflict could escalate after a scheduled tariff increase from 25% to 30% on $250 billion of Chinese imports on October 15 and the possibility of a new round of tariffs on the remaining $160 billion of goods scheduled for December 15. There is some hope that the upcoming (13th) round of trade negotiations between the U.S. and China in Washington on October 10–11 could yield a breakthrough. While that is possible, we do not think it is likely, and in any event China is unlikely to offer significant concessions on the issues that are at the heart of the Section 301 investigation: forced technology transfer and the subsidization of national champion companies. We think the specter of impeachment and the perception of an embattled President Trump will make China even more reluctant to offer these structural concessions, thereby decreasing the chances of a substantive deal anytime soon, prolonging uncertainty, and risking escalation. Possible silver lining: NAFTA 2.0 resolution On a more positive note, we think the impeachment inquiry could actually help foster resolution of another trade issue that has plagued markets – the ratification of NAFTA’s successor, the United States–Mexico–Canada Agreement (USMCA, also known as NAFTA 2.0). That is because House Speaker Nancy Pelosi and the so-called majority makers – the 31 Democrats who represent districts that voted for Trump in 2016 – want to show their constituents that they can indeed legislate. Specifically, even though most Democrats may support an impeachment inquiry – and may even vote for impeachment – they also want to be seen collaborating with the president to get important things done. The future of the USMCA also depends on whether the ongoing negotiations between the Trump administration and Democrats continue to be constructive, as well as whether organized labor groups endorse the trade agreement. But we would argue that impeachment has changed the political calculus for Speaker Pelosi around the USMCA, and that there is now more pressure to bring the trade agreement up for a vote to demonstrate that Democrats, particularly centrist Democrats, can accomplish more than simply impeachment. For the markets, this could be an important and welcome development since the ratification of the USMCA would effectively eliminate the chances that the president withdraws from the original NAFTA, thereby taking a large policy risk off the table. It could be a silver lining of impeachment. For more on policy developments that could move economies and markets, see our recent Cyclical Outlook, “Window of Weakness.” READ HERE Libby Cantrill is PIMCO’s head of public policy and a regular contributor to the PIMCO Blog.
Viewpoints Engaging With Stakeholders to Reduce Methane Emissions From Oil and Gas Production Methane emissions from oil and gas production have an outsized contribution to global warming that can be reduced in cost-effective ways, helping mitigate a significant transition risk.
Viewpoints Commodities’ Summer of Discontent: Limited Supply Flexibility Poses Material Risks Supply-side constraints on commodities pose risk to the global economy and elevate right tail risks to inflation.
Blog Assessing Inflation’s Effects Across Emerging Markets The varied responses of individual countries to global inflationary pressures have contributed to elevated real-rate differentials between developed and emerging markets.
Blog Power of Representation: the ‘Us’es’ To celebrate Pride Month, four PIMCO executives share their perspectives on inclusion and diversity in the workplace and the importance of visible representation.
Blog Secular Outlook Key Takeaways: Reaching for Resilience We believe shorter business cycles, elevated volatility, and diminished policy responses warrant a focus on portfolio resilience over reaching for yield.
Secular Outlook Reaching for Resilience Volatility, inflation, and geopolitical strain have countries and businesses focusing on defense. We argue for building resilience in portfolios in this fragmenting world, and delve into risks and opportunities we foresee over the next five years.
Viewpoints Active Versus Passive in Global Funds Active global bond funds distributed in Europe, Asia and Africa have outperformed their passive peers.
Blog Will Taxes Rise in the U.S.? Democrats could begin working on a tax bill later this year, but resulting tax hikes may be weaker and less of a headwind to growth than some fear.
Blog After Historic Market Moves, Outlook for Bonds Improves This year’s surge in yields is restoring value to the bond market, especially with the likelihood of a recession rising, although it remains uncertain when market momentum might turn.
Blog Chinese Financials Feeling the Squeeze Amid Sluggish Credit Demand Following strong double-digit profit growth in FY2021, we expect Chinese banks will be less profitable this year as COVID-19 lockdowns continue to disrupt China’s economy.